Можно ли было реформировать советскую систему

XX XXI : , , ? 1991- , , : , , — .

, , 19851991 , , ? , . , , , . ( , , .) -, , , , , , , , , . , , : ? , , [1].

, , 1991 , , , , , , , , ? , , , [2]? , . , , — , [3]. , , , .

, , . , , . , , ; , , , , . . , . , , , [4].

. . . , , ? , , , ? , , ? 8 12 200 ( 12 , , ), , , , , 腻. , . , [5].

, , — , , , , . : , , : , , , , , , . , , . , , [6]. . , , , , .

, , , , [7]. , , , [8]. , . , , ; , . , , , .

, , , .

, , . 1990 , , , 19901991 , . 1991 , .

, , , , , , 1986- 1988- ? , , , ( ), — — ? 1987 ? 19901991 , 1996-?

, , , , 1990 ? 1991- , , , ? , , , ? , 1991 , — ?

, , , : . , : , , , , . [9].

. 19851990 , : , , , . , , . , , , .

, , : , , , [10]. , , : , , , , . , 1989 , — .

, 1991 , . , , , , , — . , , [11].

, , . 19891991 , , — . , , , ( 80 , ) — — , , , , , . , , [12].

, . , 1991 93 , 76,4 9 . , , . , . 1991 , XXI 80 [13].

, , . , . 1 , , . 99 , , , , , , , , . , , [14]. (, , .)

, , , , , . , , 19851990 , , , , . , .

, , , , . , , , , . , , , , , , , , , 1930- . , , .

, , [15]. 1920- , , , 19501960- . , , , .

. , [16]. , — , ? , 1914 : — . ( 50 -, ; .) 1980- .

, , . , , . , , . , — — , . , ; , . , 1990 , . , ( ) , : [17].

, , , , , . : ; ; , , ; ; ; , , .

, , , . , , , , , . , . 1917 . 1930- . , 25 , 1950- , , .

, 1990 , , , , . , , , : ( ), 1917 , 1918- -; ; ( , ); , , , , .

, , .

. 1990- , — , -. , , , . , , . , , .

. , . , , , . , 1980-, .

, , , . 1990 , , , [18]. , , 70 ( , , ) . — , , . : , , .

, , . , , : . , , . , , , , . , , , . , , , . , 1990 : . . , , . , , , , , 70 , . , , [19].

( 1917 ), . . ( 1917-, ), , , ( , 1988 1 [20]).

. , , . , , , . , 1990 , [21].

? , , , , , . . -, , , ; -, , .

1980- , , , , , : , , , ; , , ; 19 , ; , , , 1950- . , — .

1800 [22], , 1990 , , . ( , .) , , , , . ; , , , . , 1990- , , .

, , , , . , [23]. — , . : , , . , 1991 . , , , , , , [24]. , .

, . . , , , . , , , , , , , , .

— . — . 1990 . . 1980- 1990- , , . 1991- , ; , . , , XXI .

19 . , -. 1991- 4 — , . , , . , .

, , . 80- : ; , 1917 ; , ; , 1930-; , ; 19501960- 1980-.

, , : , [25]. , , , , . ( ) , 1987 , , , , . [26]. 1991 , .

1988 , . , , , . [27]. , , 1920- . . 1989- . 87 , , , [28].

1990 — , , . , , . , . 60 , , .

, [29]. , ( , 412 1991 , [30]), , , : — — , .

1990 , . , , 1990- ( ), . — , , , , . 1991 . , .

( 1985 [31]) , , , XXI . , , — , , , , . , , ( ) , . ( , , , , 57 [32].)

, , , , . , , ( ). , , , . , 1990 , 56 , 81 , 34 [33]. , .

— , , , . , , , , . 19801990- , — — .

. , , , . (, , ) XXVIII 1990 , , 1990- 1991 , , . , , , , , [34].

, , , . , , , , , . , 1985 , , . : , , , , , . ( , .)

, . , 1989 , — . 1990 , . , , , .

, , , . , , . 1993 , . 1996 , , , 40 ( , ) , [35]. 2003 . , , .

. . , , , , , . , , , . ( ), .

. , , , , , ; . 1991 , [36]. , , . , ( 1990 ) : , , , — [37]. , , .

. , , , , , , [38]. . , , , . — , . , , , 1929 .

, , , , 1930- . , , , , , , , . . , . , , , , , , 19901991 .

, , , . , . 1990 , , , , , , . , , , : [39]. , , .

, , 1990 . [40]. , , . 1991 : [41]. , , , , , , , . , .

, . 1990 , , 200 , 5 , 5 6 . , . , . — , . 1991 [42]. , : [43]. , .

, . , , 1990 , , [44]. , : , , , . 1991- , , .

, , 1991 ? (. ) . , , , , ( ) , . , , — . ( 1917 ), , , . -: , , , — , , , .

, , . , , , , . , , , . , [45].

, , , , . , , , , . . . , , , , , , , , . , , .

. , , , , , [46]. , , 75 , 25 . , , , , , . 60 -, , [47].

, 1917 , , . , , [48]. , , . , , 1991 , , , [49].

, , , . , , , 1990 . , , 1940 , (, 1991 ). — , .

, , 810 90 , . , . , . . , , [50].

, 1990 , , . , . , , , , , , , , 1991 . ( , , , .)

, , . , 20 1991 , , , , , [51]. , , , , . : , , , [52].

, , , . ; , , , , , . , , , . , , , , [53].

, , , , 19 . ( , .) ( , , ), . , . , . ( , , , , 1991- , , , .)

, , , , , [54]. 1900 . . : ![55] , , , , , 25 1991 , , . , , , , , [56]. , , , .

, , , , . , 1991 . , , , . , , , , , [57]. , .

, , ? , ?[58] , , 1920- 1917 ; , ; , ( , ); , ; — , , , , . , , .

, , . , . , : , , , , , . , . , , . , , [59].

, , , . , , , , , . , , , , , [60]. , , .

, , , , . , , , , , . , .

[1] R. Sakwa. Gorbachev and His Reforms, 19851990. Englewood Cliffs ( N. J.), 1991. P. 357; .: Is Soviet ism Reformable? The Soviet System: From Crisis to Collapse. Ed. by A. Dallin and G. W. Lapidus. Boulder , 1995. P 320.

[2] . : A. slund. How Russia Became a Market Economy. Wash. , 1995. P. 2652;

M. S. Fish. Democracy from Scratch: Opposition and Regime in the New Russian Revolution. Princeton , 1995. P. 3; Washington Post. 15 December. 1991; B. Williams. Review on John Keeps Last of the Empires: A History of the Soviet Union , 19451991. Russian Review. 56. 1. January 1997. P. 143; D. Saunders. Review on Theodore Taranovskis ed., Reform in Modern Russian History: Progress or Cycle? Europe-Asia Studies. 48. 5. July 1996. P. 868.

[3] M. Malia. Leninist Endgame. Daedalus. 121. 2. Spring 1992. P. 60; A. Besanson. Breaking the Spell. Can the Soviet System Survive Reform? Seven Colloquies the e of Soviet ism Seventy Years after the Bolshevik Revolution. Ed. by G. R. Urban. L., 1989. P. 202.

[4] . M. Malia. The Soviet Tragedy: A History of ism in Russia , 19171991. N. Y., 1994. P. 5; M. Malia, Stephen R. Graubard. The Mystery of Z. Bulletin of the American Academy of Arts and Sciences. 44. 2. November 1990. P. 8; M. Malia. To the Stalin Mausoleum. The Soviet System: From Crisis to Collapse. P. 667.

[5] . : R. L. Garthoff. The Great Transition: American-Soviet Relations and the End of the Cold War. Wash. , 1994. P. 352.

[6] . M. Dobbs. Strobe Talbott and the Cursed Questions. Washington Post Magazine. 9 June. 1996. P. 11; R. Service. A History of Twentieth-Century Russia . Washington Post Book World. 22 March. 1998. P. 10.

[7] (Reinhard Bendix) (. : A. Dallin. Causes of the Collapse of the USSR . The Soviet System: From Crisis to Collapse. P. 688).

[8] ., : A. Braun, R. B. Day. Gorbachevian Contradictions. Problems of Communism. 39. 3. MayJune 1990. P. 3650; D. Simes. Gorbachevs of Troubles. Foreign Policy. 82. Spring 1991. P. 97117; A. slund. Gorbachevs Struggle for Economic Reform. Ithaca , 1991; M. I. Goldman. What Went Wrong with Perestroika. N. Y., 1991. P. 210219.

[9] C. : C. McGiffert Ekedahl, M. A. Goodman. The Wars of Eduard Shevardnadze. University Park (PA), 1997. P. 50; G. Chiesa. Transition to Democracy: Political Change in the Soviet Union , 19871991. Hanover , 1993. P. 203; P. Rutland. Sovietology: Who Got It Right and Who Got It Wrong? Rethinking the Soviet Collapse: Sovietology, the Death of Communism and the New Russia . Ed. by M. Cox. N. Y., 1998. P. 43.

[10] ( Rasma Karklins) ( J. Keep. Last of the Empires: A History of the Soviet Union , 19451991. N. Y., 1995. P. 416).

[11] . D. M. Kotz, F. Weir. Revolution from Above: The Demise of the Soviet System. N. Y., 1997. P. 239; New York s. 09.01.2000; M. S. Fish. Democracy From Scratch: Opposition and Regime in the New Russian Revolution. Princeton , 1995. P. 3, 51; St. Kotkin. The e Is It Us? Memoirs, s, and Kremlinologists. Russian Review. 61. 1. January 2002. P. 50; New York s. 02.05.1998.

[12] . . . : 19851991. ., 2002. . 326.

[13] . M. Wyman. Public Opinion in Postcommunist Russia . N. Y., 1997; Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty Newsline. 16.03.2001; S. White. Gorbachev and After. N. Y., 1992. P. 180181.

[14] . A. Lebed. My Life and My Country. Wash. , 1997. P. 321; R. Braithwaite. Across the Moscow River : The World Turned Upside Down. New Haven , 2002. P. 242; . 2329.08.2001.

[15] Ph. G. Roeder. Red Sunset: The Failure of Soviet Politics. Princeton , 1993. P. 5.

[16] ., : M. Kammen. A Season of Youth: The American Revolution and Historical Imagination. N. Y., 1978.

[17] . . BBC, 8 2002. Johnsons Russia List ( list). 20.03.2002.

[18] ., : R. Sakwa. Gorbachev and His Reforms. P. 192; J. Gooding. Perestroika as Revolution from Within: An Interpretation. Russian Review. 51. 1. January 1992. P. 3657; G. Chiesa. Transition to Democracy. P. 3.

[19] . . 13.04.1990; . 27.02.1990.

[20] . . (. 11.11.1988).

[21] . E. Teague. Constitutional Watchdog Suspends Presidential Decree. Radio Liberty Report on the USSR . 2. 42. 19.10.1990. P. 910.

[22] . . : . ., 1996. . 75.

[23] . . . . : . ., 1993. . 356.

[24] . G. Gill. The Collapse of a -Party System: The Disintegration of the Communist Party of the Soviet Union . N. Y., 1995. P. 17475; . . . . 2- . ., 1995. . 2. . 575; B. Kagarlitsky. Square Wheels: How Russian Democracy Got Derailed. N. Y., 1994. P. 142.

[25] . . . . ., 1997. . 35; . 57 1990 . ., 1990. . 1112.

[26] . 01.07.1991.

[27] (. . 03.03.1988; . 05.04.1988).

[28] . XIX . . 2- . ., 1988. . 2. . 88, 175.

[29] . 02.07.1991; . 26.09.1990.

[30] . : . 12.05.1991.

[31] . . . : . , 1994. . 1722, 205212.

[32] . . . . . 2. . 578.

[33] . 26.09.1990.

[34] ., , . (14.01.1990).

[35] . J. B. Urban, V. D. Solovei. Russia s Communists at the Crossroads. Boulder , 1997; M. Luke. The Communist Party in Post-Soviet Russia . N. Y., 2002.

[36] ., : A. slund. How Russia Became a Market Economy. P. 28.

[37] . . 18.09.1990; 26.04.1990.

[38] A. slund. How Russia Became a Market Economy. P. 28; R. Service. A History of Twentieth-Century Russia . Cambridge ( Mass. ), 1997. P. 492.

[39] P. Desai. Perestroika in Perspective. Princeton , 1990. P. 106.

[40] ., , , . , 1991 , , , (. A. slund. How Russia Became a Market Economy. P. 30).

[41] . 08.06.1991.

[42] Washington Post. 0709.07.1991.

[43] . Moscow s. 12.03.1995.

[44] . : . . , 1113 1990 . ., 1990.

[45] . St. Kotkin. Trashcanistan. New Republic. 15.04.2002; R. Pipes, Communism: A History.

L., 1994. P. 41; A. Nove. The Fall of Empires: Russia and the Soviet Union . The Fall of Great Powers: Peace, Stability, and Legitimacy. Ed. by G. Lundestad. Oslo , 1994. P. 144.

[46] V. Shlapentokh. A Normal Totalitarian Society: How the Soviet Union ed and How It Collapsed. Armonk, 2001. P. 164166.

[47] . . . . . . 132; V. Shlapentokh.

A Normal Totalitarian Society. P. 158.

[48] St. Kotkin. Trashcanistan. P. 27.

[49] R. G. Suny. The Revenge of the Past: Nationalism, Revolution, and the Collapse of the Soviet Union . Stanford, 1993. P. 150.

[50] FBIS. 30.09.1991. P. 70.

[51] . . 15.08.1991.

[52] . M. Gorbachev. On My Country and the World. N. Y., 2000. P. 132; Johnsons Russia List. 20.08.2001.

[53] . : A. Brown. The Gorbachev Factor. N. Y., 1997. P. 293.

[54] ., , . , . . , : ( FBIS. 13.09.1991, P. 33; 30.09.1991. P. 70; 02.10.1991. P. 33).

[55] . : . . , ! ., 1997. . 110.

[56] C. . 27.11.1991.

[57] ., , . ( New York s. 03.09.1998) . (New Republic. 31.03.2003. P. 34).

[58] . R. Strayer. Why Did the Soviet Union Collapse? Understanding Historical Change. Armonk, 1998. P. 113.

[59] (J. N. Hazard. The Soviet System of Government. Chicago, 1980). , 1957 , , . , (. B. Moore, Jr. Soviet Politics. The Dilemmas of Power: The Role of Ideas in Change. N. Y., 1965; 1950 ).

[60] . : . . . . 7- . ., 19871990. . 6.

. 352; . . . 1. . 390; 10 : , — — 2001 . ., 2002.

. 8; . . . . . 1. . 423.